|
There's been a good deal of discussion on this topic in many
places, including our Sailnet email discussion group. I have my own opinions [these are not endorsed by Catalina],
generated by many years working with antennas/electronics for military
aircraft. However, as lightning protection is so uncertain -- there are
no guarantees -- it's a good idea to review some reference material,
so you can make a so-called informed decision as to what, if anything, to
do. This whole topic can be pretty controversial: I invite [as always] any
comments, contrary or not.
The basic reference is the ABYC lightning protection standards [section
E-4], which are included in your C380/390 manual [note that a 1998 change
requires minimum grounding/bonding conductors to be #6]; it's also
available at www.abycinc.org. Another
reference is Professor E. Thomson's [U. Fla.] extensive website at
www.thomson.ece.ufl/lightning/. On
the latter, you can download an article that gives a nice summary of his
research and recommendations. Also,
take a look at our C380/390 website, where Jim Jaeschke, our
Secretary/Treasurer, has written a relevant installation article [see
Technical Section, Electrical/Electronics Page]. Lastly, see Cruising
World Dec. 2001.
The following approach is aimed principally at captain's who have not done
anything about lightning protection, and have probably wondered what to
do. Please note two important points: [1] statistics on boats that have
been struck show more damage for boats without some protection as compared
to those with protection [see Thomson] and, [2] contrary to
"semi-popular" opinion, there is no evidence that adding a
grounding system increases the probability of receiving a lightning
strike. So, let's do something! The
technique described here is very easy to implement, and may offer a lot
"bang for the bucks" [this may not be a good simile!]-- so no
more excuses! This approach
is also mentioned in my boat's Catalina handbook, par. 6.0, #2.
Keep Currents Outside
Because aircraft are so susceptible to lightning strikes and
negative results potentially so disastrous, great emphasis is placed on
lightning protection, specifically keeping the resulting high currents on
the outside of the vehicle; this approach theoretically eliminates
interior damage and, in the practical sense, it works.
Obviously, with a conducting skin, an airplanes configuration is
much more amenable to this approach than are our sailboats.
But we do have a "thinned" skin in the sense of our stays
& shrouds. Therefore, if they are grounded to the water outside the
hull, then current generated by lightning striking the masthead [or vhf
antenna there] has some probability of entering the water never having
entered our boat. If this
happens [nothing is sure here!], then it seems to me there's much less
likely a chance of significant damage to people, hull, or equipment inside
the cabin.
Grounding Techniques
To ground the stays and shrouds, some captains use battery
cables, with one end clamped to a chain plate, and the other tossed into
the water. Obviously, this is typically a temporary setup, at least for
the shrouds, as their grounding cables would be in the way to anyone
walking forward on deck. On the other hand, it's so easy to deploy.
In some situations I prefer chain, as standard anchor chain, rather
than battery cables/clamps, is
much less susceptible to salt-water corrosion.
At any rate, the idea is to deploy the [upper & mid] shroud ground
straps only under impending storm conditions, and perhaps anytime your
boat is docked, anchored or moored. A forward grounding chain, attached to
the stay chainplate, can be left in place virtually all the time, unless
you find it scrapes on the hull when underway, in which case it can
conveniently be stored in the chain locker. Aft grounding, attached to one
or preferably both of the split backstays, would definitely rub on the
hull, so this is another temporary ground location, unless you can work
out some way of not messing-up the transom.
The second line of defense with this approach is to add grounding of the
mast base and the lower shrouds/chainplates.
This is because of the very large electro-magnetic fields
associated with lightning and it's propensity to induce large currents in
nearby conductors, particularly those that are parallel.
Another battery cable clamped near the bottom of the mast and one
of the upper/mid chainplates should do it; here the battery cable should
be just the right length: this conductor should be as straight as
possible. Bonding together
the three chainplates on each side is a bit trickier: either two special,
short 3-clamp cables can be used externally, or they can be permanently
connected by heavy cable immediately under the deck.
I know this is inside the boat, but only barely inside, and is not
in an area like a wet bilge, subject to significant corrosion potential.
Battery Cables vs. Chain
As mentioned above, I sometimes prefer chain, because of the
potential salt-water corrosion to [mostly] copper battery cables/clamps. A
concern here is the questionable conductivity of chain, given the steel
makeup and potential resistance between links.
However, the idea here is that any conductor acts as a
"guide" to lightning [at least some think so!], with some
current in the conductor and some in the surrounding ionized air; the
better the conductor, the more energy would normally enter that conductor
and less would be in the air. However,
as we're talking external [to boat] use of chain, it's less important that
all current be fully "contained".
Conversely, for lightning grounding inside your boat, NEVER use
chain or any questionable conductor and NEVER have any poor connections.
A
reasonable compromise re cable/chain is to use battery cables for the
shrouds, where they would normally be temporary and therefore less
corrosion-likely. I would
also suggest that they be rinsed in fresh water and sprayed with WD-40
after each use; still they may need replacement more often than you'd
like. Another idea is to clip a 3-foot length of chain to the lower
cable clamp, thus keeping the copper out of the water. Of course, you'd
need short [about 4-feet] battery cables.
Length Submersed
How much chain/cable in the water? ABYC suggests that a square foot conducting area is
sufficient to dissipate a typical lightning strike in salt water [much
more in fresh water]. For a
5/16" diameter battery cable, this translates to a length of about 12
feet, maybe a bit less allowing for a clamp --not at all practical. If a
full-size plate can be included, then a grounding cable only need be long
enough to get the plate submerged.
5/16" chain has more surface area/length; about five feet
length in the water has a square foot area.
That's still a bit much--I compromise with about half that.
Again, adding a plate reduces the need for length in the water.
However, any plates used are probably more likely to scrape against
the hull, especially at a "rolly" anchorage, so consider that in
your design.
What To Do?
There are three principal categories of lightning-protected
boats: [1] those with no protection, [2] those with external grounding,
such as described above, and [3] those with internal grounding.
The vast majority seems to be split between [1] and [3]; the reason
the internal method is as popular is probably because it's permanent: you
can't forget to implement it as might be the case for [2].
I don't know of any evidence [except for aircraft/external] indicating
which grounding method is better [obviously
both together is better]. Also,
there is some evidence showing that adding grounding does not increase the
likelihood of receiving a lightning strike.
So, if you've been putting off adding internal grounding because
it's difficult to implement, then consider the external approach: it can
be added in minutes [maybe an hour or two, allowing for parts shopping
time], and may provide a significant degree of personnel/boat safety.
At least it should make you feel better while hunkering down during
a big storm.
Internal Grounding: Be Careful
A caution on the other method: grounding inside your boat [eg:
mast/compression post to keel]. Once
having implemented some sort of internal ground, theoretically lightning
currents will be encouraged to follow that path, even if the ground path
is not perfect. So, with very
high currents inside, where people may be and where the hull is, it is
imperative to make that connection "robust", to say the least.
This means that grounding cables must be very heavy [the thickest
battery cable or copper straps that can be fit; # 6 minimum per ABYC], and
the connections essentially perfect.
Consider a lightning strike delivering 100,000 amps of current
[typical in military aircraft work], then a connection with a resistance
of only 0.1 ohms [very tiny in the electronics field] will end up with
10,000 volts across it, enough for some serious damage.
So, make sure those connections are "squeaky clean",
perhaps disassembling and cleaning at least once per season. Corrosion, a
common source of resistance, is especially likely on keel bolts because of
bilge moisture; inspect this lightning ground connection regularly,
particularly if you have a wet bilge.
I mention keel bolts, because the keel is the grounding "plate"
most often used [Prof. Thomson says this is OK even if the keel is
encapsulated in some fiberglass]. The
first line of defense here is to connect the bottom of the compression
post [which is "connected" to the mast via the mast step].
The next step is grounding the shroud tierods, followed by forward
and aft stay chainplates. The
next priority is to "bond" together [and tie to ground] as much
of the large metal items as possible; for example: the aft pulpit and
Edson pedestal. The idea here
is to provide a "short circuit" between them that reduces
[hopefully to zero] the voltage which might otherwise appear between them
due to side flashes and very high fields.
Lastly, for the best chance of saving electronics such as the VHF,
I suggest disconnecting the antenna and shorting the radio's input [short
circuit type RF connector preferred]; meanwhile, ground the antenna cable
well. But don't play with any
of this if lightning is imminent!
I intended this section to serve as a caution regarding the need for
careful grounding connections inside the boat, so it is rather cursory
regarding grounding installation. Therefore
please refer to the ABYC Standards, Professor Thomson or any other
expert's info before implementing any of this.
Conclusions: Safety First
Personnel safety is, of course, of utmost importance in all
of this. That's the main
reason the keep-it-on-the-outside approach appeals to me: anyone on board
during a lightning storm is likely to be in the cabin, or could go there,
where they will be further from likely high currents and/or voltages as
compared to internal grounding. This also works for boat and equipment
survival. Of course, this
assumes any strike currents will follow the intended paths, but nothing is
certain! The other aspect of
safety is to keep away from metal, such as the wheel, chainplate tierods,
etc. during a storm.
It seems like I've spent enough time on this subject......so, consider
what you've read, maybe carry a couple of battery cables at-the-ready, and
enjoy your C380/390's: great boats in any weather.
|